Hockey Stick

A reconstruction of temperatures over the past 1,000 years prominently featured in the IPCC Third Assessment Report, commonly used to illustrate global warming.
On this page

Background

The term “hockey stick” refers to a specific reconstruction of global temperatures over the last millennium, highlighting significant trends in historical climate data. The graph acquired its name due to its shape, which closely resembles a hockey stick: a long, flat shaft representing relatively constant temperatures over a substantial pre-industrial period, followed by a sharp upward curve in the 20th century, indicating a steep rise in global temperatures.

Historical Context

The “hockey stick” graph gained prominence after its inclusion in the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) Third Assessment Report in 2001. The temperature reconstruction was primarily developed through principal components analysis of proxy data sources such as tree rings, ice cores, and other historical climate indicators.

Definitions and Concepts

  • Proxy Data: Indirect measurements of climate variables derived from tree rings, ice cores, and other historical records.
  • Principal Components Analysis (PCA): A statistical technique used to simplify complex datasets by reducing their dimensions, often utilized for patterns in proxy climate data.

Major Analytical Frameworks

Historical Climate Data Analysis

Historical climate data analysis involves combining various forms of proxy data to simulate past climate behavior and identify long-term trends. Methods utilized include principal components analysis and other statistical techniques to create models like the hockey stick graph.

Comparative Analysis

Early Criticisms

Criticism of the hockey stick graph arose around methodological concerns. Initial scrutiny emphasized potential inaccuracies in the dataset, raising questions about the reliability and robustness of conclusions derived from the principal components analysis.

Later Developments

Subsequent reviews and re-analyses unveiled additional complications, including potential data selection biases and issues regarding statistical significance. As a result, various experts, including A. W. Montford, challenged the validity of the hockey stick graph, describing it as a “corruption of science.”

Case Studies

Empirical evaluation of the hockey stick graph has prompted significant academic discourse, culminating in a diverse array of studies, both supporting and critiquing its methodology and conclusions.

Suggested Books for Further Studies

  • “The Hockey Stick and the Climate Wars” by Michael E. Mann
  • “Hockey Stick Illusion,” by A.W. Montford
  • Climate Change: Long-term alteration in Earth’s climate, often associated with global warming and other global-scale environmental changes.
  • Global Warming: The gradual increase in Earth’s average surface temperature due to high levels of carbon dioxide, chlorofluorocarbons, and other pollutants.
  • Principal Components Analysis (PCA): A statistical procedure that converts a set of correlated variables into uncorrelated variables called principal components, useful in reducing the complexity of climate data.

Quiz

### What does the 'hockey stick' diagram represent? - [x] A sharp rise in temperature over the last century following a period of stability - [ ] Continuous rising temperatures throughout the last millennium - [ ] Stable temperatures with minimal fluctuations - [ ] A gradual decline in temperatures over the past 1,000 years > **Explanation:** The 'hockey stick' diagram is characterized by a long period of stable temperatures followed by a sharp rise in the 20th century. ### Which principle statistical method was used in constructing the 'hockey stick'? - [ ] Regression Analysis - [x] Principal Components Analysis - [ ] Correlation - [ ] Time Series Analysis > **Explanation:** Principal Components Analysis was the key method used to derive the 'hockey stick' model from proxy data. ### What did the 'hockey stick' model symbolize in the context of climate change? - [x] Evidence of significant global warming in the 20th century - [ ] Continuity of stable temperature in history - [ ] Mitigation of greenhouse gases - [ ] Cool trends across centuries > **Explanation:** The 'hockey stick' was taken as substantial evidence for the notable increase in global temperatures in the 20th century. ### True or False: The 'hockey stick' graph indicated previous centuries with higher temperatures than the present. - [ ] True - [x] False > **Explanation:** The 'hockey stick' graph mainly showed stability in temperature before the sharp rise in the 20th century. ### Are proxy data directly measured climate data? - [ ] Yes - [x] No > **Explanation:** Proxy data are indirect measures used to infer past climatic conditions, unlike directly measured data. ### Which organization gave prominence to the 'hockey stick' in its reports? - [ ] WHO - [ ] UNESCO - [x] IPCC - [ ] WTO > **Explanation:** The IPCC highlighted the 'hockey stick' reconstruction in its 2001 Third Assessment Report. ### The major criticism towards the 'hockey stick' focused on? - [ ] Its visual representation - [ ] Meteorological predictions - [x] Statistical techniques and data used - [ ] Climatic density > **Explanation:** The primary criticism was aimed at the statistical methodologies and the proxy data selection. ### Who authored a notable book about the 'hockey stick' controversies? - [x] A. W. Montford - [ ] Al Gore - [ ] Bill McKibben - [ ] James Hansen > **Explanation:** A. W. Montford wrote extensively on the controversies surrounding the 'hockey stick.' ### What is the central visual feature of the 'hockey stick' graph? - [ ] Steadfast fluctuations - [ ] Gradual decline - [ ] Irregular meteor patterns - [x] Sharp uptick in the modern era > **Explanation:** The central idea is the sharp upward turn, suggesting a significant rise in temperature during the modern era. ### In what context is the 'hockey stick' metaphor used? - [x] Climate Science - [ ] Stock Market Trends - [ ] Sports Analysis - [ ] Technological Progress > **Explanation:** Primarily, the 'hockey stick' metaphor is relevant to Climate Science, representing rapid temperature changes in the 20th century.
Hog Cycle
HM Treasury