Adverse Selection

An economics term defined as the tendency for a contract to attract the types of agent that are least profitable for the issuer, often due to asymmetric information.
On this page

In one sentence

Adverse selection happens when one side of a transaction has better information (about quality or risk) and that hidden information causes the “worse” types to participate more, making the market work poorly.

Classic example (Akerlof’s lemons)

If sellers know whether a used car is good or a “lemon” but buyers cannot tell, buyers offer a lower average price. Good-car sellers then exit, leaving more lemons in the market. The average quality falls further, and the market can unravel.

Where it shows up in economics

  • Insurance: higher-risk people are more likely to buy generous coverage.
  • Credit: borrowers most likely to default are more eager to borrow at a given interest rate.
  • Labor markets: employers cannot fully observe worker ability at hiring time.

How markets try to fix it

Two broad families of solutions:

  • Signaling (informed side reveals type): credentials, warranties, brand reputation.
  • Screening (uninformed side designs menus): deductibles and copays in insurance, collateral requirements in lending.

A simple “lemons” pricing condition

Suppose there are good cars worth $v_G$ and lemons worth $v_L$ with $v_G > v_L$, and buyers cannot distinguish them. If the share of good cars offered for sale is $q$, the competitive price buyers are willing to pay is the expected value:

\[ P = \mathbb{E}[v] = q\,v_G + (1-q)\,v_L \]

If this price is below what good-car sellers are willing to accept (for example, if $P < v_G$), good types exit, $q$ falls, and the price falls further—this feedback is the adverse selection spiral.

The adverse selection spiral

    flowchart TD
	  A["Hidden type: quality or risk"] --> B["Single price/contract offered"]
	  B --> C["High-risk / low-quality types join more"]
	  C --> D["Average outcome worsens<br/>(higher claims, defaults, breakdowns)"]
	  D --> E["Price rises or terms worsen"]
	  E --> F["Low-risk / high-quality types exit"]
	  F --> C
  • Asymmetric Information: A market situation where one party, typically the buyer or the seller, has more or better information than the other.
  • Moral Hazard: When a party to a contract can alter their behavior to the detriment of another party after the contract has been signed, often occurs in conjunction with adverse selection.
  • Market Failure: A situation in which a market left on its own fails to allocate resources efficiently due to reasons like externalities, public goods, or information asymmetries.

Quiz

### What is Adverse Selection? - [x] An issue where contracts attract high-risk individuals. - [ ] A scenario where market opportunities are equally balanced. - [ ] A concept unrelated to information asymmetry. - [ ] A marketing strategy to attract more customers. > **Explanation:** Adverse selection is specifically an issue where contracts disproportionately attract high-risk individuals due to information asymmetry. ### Which Nobel laureate discussed adverse selection in the context of used car markets? - [ ] Kenneth Arrow - [ ] Paul Krugman - [ ] Milton Friedman - [x] George Akerlof > **Explanation:** George Akerlof discussed adverse selection in his 1970 paper, "The Market for 'Lemons'". ### What technique involves informed parties revealing their type to address adverse selection? - [x] Signaling - [ ] Screening - [ ] Market Signage - [ ] Information Dumping > **Explanation:** Signaling is where informed parties (like job seekers) reveal their type to mitigate adverse selection. ### True or False: Asymmetric information only impacts insurance markets. - [ ] True - [x] False > **Explanation:** Asymmetric information affects various markets, including automotive, rental, and financial markets. ### What does adverse selection often lead to? - [x] Market failure - [ ] Market efficiency - [ ] Increased competition - [ ] Innovation > **Explanation:** Adverse selection typically leads to market inefficiency and may even cause market failure. ### Which concept is a concern after a contract is signed, due to parties taking on more risk knowing they are protected? - [ ] Adverse Selection - [x] Moral Hazard - [ ] Screening - [ ] Signaling > **Explanation:** Moral hazard occurs after a contract is signed, where parties may take on additional risks they wouldn't have otherwise. ### In which sector besides insurance is adverse selection a common problem? - [ ] Horticulture - [x] Used car markets - [ ] Software development - [ ] Agricultural markets > **Explanation:** Adverse selection is notably problematic in used car markets, as highlighted by George Akerlof. ### Which regulatory body aims to address adverse selection in the health insurance market through the ACA? - [ ] NAIC - [ ] FDA - [ ] FCC - [x] No single regulator; rules vary by country/state > **Explanation:** Adverse selection in insurance is addressed through rules like mandatory coverage, risk adjustment, and standardized benefits, but the responsible bodies vary across jurisdictions. ### True or False: Adverse selection can be entirely eliminated with perfect screening methods. - [ ] True - [x] False > **Explanation:** While it can be mitigated, adverse selection is challenging to entirely eliminate due to ongoing information asymmetry. ### What does the term 'asymmetric information' imply in economic transactions? - [ ] Both parties know everything. - [ ] One party hides assets intentionally. - [x] One party has more or better information. - [ ] Information is symmetrically distributed. > **Explanation:** "Asymmetric information" means one party possesses more or otherwise superior information.
Adverse Supply Shock
Advantage